Best Throw Pillow Inserts

You’ve splashed out on a new set of throw pillows for your couch, living room, or bedroom. However, you didn’t realize that you weren’t buying the complete throw pillows themselves. When your new throw pillows arrived in the mail, you only got the covers included. Where are the throw pillow inserts?

The frustrating thing with most throw pillows is that you often need to buy the throw pillow inserts separately. This means having to ensure that you buy the correct size insert for the covers that you have already purchased.

Sometimes there may be a couple of inches extra needed so that the insert will fit into the throw pillow case you’ve bought. But how can you find the best throw pillow inserts?

That’s where we come in. We’ve done all the hard work for you so that you don’t have to. We’ve researched and reviewed hundreds of products to help you find the best of the best. We’ve whittled it down to the 5 best throw pillow inserts on the market. Let’s take a look at the best throw pillow inserts!

OUR TOP PICK

Utopia Bedding Throw Pillows Insert (Pack of 2, White) - 20 x 20 Inches Bed and Couch Pillows - Indoor Decorative Pillows

The Utopia Bedding Throw Pillows Inserts are just the thing you need to fill your throw pillow covers. This particular set gives you two throw pillow inserts to work with, so you can fill your new throw pillow covers and place them on your couch. All you need to do is fluff your new throw pillow inserts once you remove them from the packaging, and they’ll be ready to go.

These particular throw pillow inserts have been made using a fiber filling. The throw pillow insert features a white poly cotton cover, and a siliconized fiber filling which will be the perfect alternative to feather throw pillow inserts. This will make the Utopia Bedding throw pillow inserts the ideal choice for those who suffer from allergies.

Another great feature of these particular throw pillow inserts is that there are multiple sizes available. There are 10 different sizes to choose from, so you can easily select the best size for your throw pillow covers.

If you prefer a fuller pillow, you may wish to order a size up. However, some customers found that this overstuffed the pillow for their liking. Choosing the best size will come down to your personal preference and how full you prefer your throw pillows.

You won’t have to worry about this throw pillow letting you down over time. It features high quality brushed poly cotton fabric to ensure that the throw pillows last you for even longer. It’s also super easy to clean the throw pillow inserts by hand or by using spot cleaning should they get dirty.

Pros:

  • Multiple sizes - choose the best throw pillow insert size for your needs
  • 2 throw pillow inserts - save money by buying two pillow inserts in a single pack
  • Hypoallergenic - constructed using a brushed poly cotton fabric and siliconized fiber filling

Cons:

  • Flat - need to follow the included instructions to fluff the throw pillows up

EDITORS CHOICE

Foamily Throw Pillows Insert 24 x 24 Inches - Bed and Couch Decorative Pillow - Made in USA

The Foamily Premium Hypoallergenic Throw Pillow Insert is an excellent choice if you only need a single product. If you have only one throw pillow cover that you need to fill, you will get the single throw pillow insert you need. This will save you from having to buy multiple covers to use any additional pillow inserts that are supplied with competitive products.

What’s really great about this Foamily throw pillow insert is that it’s hypoallergenic. It has been filled using 100% hypoallergenic polyester microfiber so will be a fantastic alternative to down pillows. This will be ideal for those who suffer from allergies. It has also been manufactured right here in America.

It’s recommended to order a size up than you need with this throw pillow insert, as the pillow insert tends to decrease in size by around 10% to 15%. By ordering the next size up, you can ensure that you have a comfy throw pillow to use in your home. The manufacturer recommends ordering 2 inches up. So if you have an 18 inches x 18 inches throw pillow cover, you should order a 20 inches x 20 inches throw pillow insert.

A handy feature of this particular throw pillow insert is that there are multiple sizes for you to choose from. There are 9 different sizes to opt for, from 12 inches x 12 inches all the way up to 28 inches x 28 inches. This will allow you to choose the best sized throw pillow insert for your needs.

Pros:

  • Multiple sizes - choose between 9 different sizes for your throw pillow covers
  • Hypoallergenic - manufactured using a 100% hypoallergenic polyester microfiber filling
  • USA made - manufactured right here in the USA

Cons:

  • Compressed - need to fluff the pillow inserts a little

BEST VALUE

Edow Throw Pillow Inserts, Set of 2 Lightweight Down Alternative Polyester Pillow, Couch Cushion, Sham Stuffer, Machine Washable. (White, 18x18)

The Edow Throw Pillow Inserts are an excellent choice if you want to get more bang for your buck. These particular throw pillow inserts are available as a pack of 2, so you will get more value for your money. This will be great if you have multiple throw pillow covers you need to fill. They also come with a 12 month warranty to give you extra peace of mind.

These particular throw pillow inserts are available in multiple sizes. This will give you more choice in terms of what size to opt for so that you can fill your two pillow covers.

There are 10 different sizes to choose from, which will give you more than enough options. Another handy feature of these particular throw pillow inserts is that you also have a choice of color. Choose between white or gray.

What’s really great about these throw pillow inserts is that they have been manufactured using an upgraded microfiber polyester filler. This makes the throw pillow inserts hypoallergenic and will be a better fit for those who suffer from allergies. The throw pillow inserts have a great spring back, and will give you the support you need.

It couldn’t be easier to clean these throw pillow inserts. They are suitable for a gentle machine wash to make things super easy for you. You can also dry the throw pillow inserts in your dryer, or by leaving them to dry in the sun.

Pros:

  • Pack of 2 - you get 2 throw pillow inserts for the price of 1
  • Multiple sizes - there are multiple throw pillow inserts for you to choose from
  • Easy to clean - suitable for machine washing on a gentle cycle

Cons:

  • Size up - some customers recommended ordering a size up if you like fuller throw pillows

RUNNER UP

Phantoscope 18 x 18 Pillow Inserts, Set of 4 Hypoallergenic Square Form Decorative Throw Pillow Inserts Couch Sham Cushion Stuffer - 18 inches

The Phantoscope Throw Pillow Inserts are an excellent choice if you want real value for money. These particular throw pillow inserts come as a pack of 4, which will give you more than enough inserts for your collection of throw pillow covers. These are a great choice if you have multiple covers that you need to fill, as it will save you from having to purchase multiple inserts.

You won’t have to worry about these throw pillow inserts letting you down. These particular throw pillow inserts feature superior construction to ensure that they last you for many years to come. They have been constructed using an upgraded polyester filling using tight stitching to ensure that the throw pillow insert is ultra tough. These throw pillow inserts are also super soft, and will give you the support you need.

What’s really handy about these particular throw pillow inserts is that they are available in multiple sizes. There are 6 different sizes for you to choose from, so you can easily select the best size for your needs. It’s recommended that you order a size larger than the size of the throw pillow covers you have so that you can have a fuller throw pillow.

These particular throw pillow inserts arrive vacuum packed to make it easier to ship them. It’s super easy to fluff them up once you’ve unpacked them so that you can get the support you need.

Pros:

  • Pack of 4 - 4 throw pillow inserts included to give you better value for money
  • Durable - features sturdy construction and superior materials for durability
  • Multiple sizes - choose between 6 different sizes for your throw pillow covers

Cons:

  • Size up - recommended to order a size up if you prefer fuller throw pillows

RUNNER UP

Oubonun 18 x 18 Pillow Inserts (Set of 2) - Throw Pillow Inserts with 100% Cotton Cover - 18 Inch Square Interior Sofa Pillow Inserts - Decorative Pillow Insert Pair - White Couch Pillow

The Oubonun Throw Pillow Inserts make the perfect choice if you have 2 throw pillow covers to fill. These particular throw pillow inserts are available in packs of 2 so that you get even more value for your money. This will be great if you’re working to a budget.

What’s really great about these particular throw pillow inserts is that you can choose between multiple sizes. So if you have a range of throw pillow covers that you need to fill, you can buy multiple sizes to suit your needs. There are 6 different sizes to choose from, ranging between 12 inches x 20 inches up to 24 inches x 24 inches.

These particular throw pillow inserts are super easy to clean should they get dirty. They can be washed by hand, or can be lightly washed using a mild detergent. They are also suitable for use in the tumble dryer to dry them out properly. This will make the throw pillow inserts much easier to clean than products that have to be taken to the dry cleaners.

A great feature of these particular throw pillow inserts is that they come with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. So if you’re not 100% satisfied with your purchase for whatever reason, you can send them back to the manufacturer for your money back.

Pros:

  • Pack of 2 - you’ll get 2 throw pillow inserts for the price of 1
  • Multiple sizes - choose between 6 different sizes for your covers
  • Easy to clean - choose between hand washing or washing with a mild detergent

Cons:

  • Sizes - you may wish to order a size up or down depending on how full you prefer your throw pillows

Best Throw Pillow Inserts Buying Guide

Looking for the best throw pillow inserts can be a real challenge. There are so many different factors to consider. If you’ve never bought throw pillow inserts before, you may feel a little overwhelmed and not know which features you should prioritize. Should you opt for the same size as the throw pillow case? Should you get a slightly smaller size so that the throw pillow covers will definitely fit?

We’ve put together this handy buyer’s guide to help you. We’ve collated a list of all the essential features you will need to look for or bear in mind when it comes to choosing your next throw pillow inserts. This should help you to make a fully informed decision and choose the throw pillow inserts that best fit your needs.

Take a look at everything you need to know about throw pillow inserts below, or skip ahead to the frequently asked questions.

Number of pillow inserts

One of the most important factors you will have to consider is how many throw pillow inserts are included in your purchase. Depending on how many throw pillow covers you have bought previously, this will dictate how many inserts you need to buy.

Some products will sell only a single throw pillow insert. Others will include packs of 2 or even 4 pillow inserts.

So it will be crucial to know beforehand how many inserts you need to buy for all your covers. If you need to buy multiple inserts, then you can opt for a set that includes as many as you need.

Hypoallergenic

If you suffer from allergies to feather pillow inserts, you will need to opt for a pillow insert that is hypoallergenic. This will mean choosing a synthetic insert made from a polyester microfiber filling.

This won’t set off any allergies you have, so you will be able to use these throw pillows on your skin or near your face should you wish to.

Size

It will be important to consider the size insert that you need before you purchase them. While most covers will feature a size of, for example, 18 inches x 18 inches, this isn’t typically the size pillow insert you would buy. 

If you prefer your throw pillow to be fuller, then you will want to opt for a throw pillow insert that is around 2 inches larger. So if your throw pillow covers are 18 inches x 18 inches, you will need to opt for an insert that measures 20 inches x 20 inches.

Or if you prefer your throw pillows to not appear to be overstuffed, then you can opt for the same size insert as your pillow cover.

Easy to clean

You will want to opt for a set of throw pillow inserts that will be easy to clean. This will make your life easier should they get dirty at any point. It will be important to know whether you need to handwash your new throw pillow inserts, or whether they are machine washable.

It will also be worth checking to see if they are suitable for tumble drying.

Durable

Opting for a throw pillow insert that is sturdy and durable will ensure that they last you for many years to come. Take a look at the materials used in construction. How tight are the stitches? These will all play a factor in how long the throw pillow inserts will last you. It will be crucial to opt for a set that features superior construction so that you won’t have to replace them in a couple of months’ or years’ time.

Budget

Another factor which may come into play is your budget. It will be important to know how many throw pillow inserts you need to purchase beforehand so that you can opt for the right product. There’s no point in choosing a product which only gives you 1 throw pillow insert if you need 4. In this case, you should opt for the product that gives you the correct number of throw pillow inserts.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best throw pillow inserts?

The best throw pillow inserts are:

  • Utopia Bedding Throw Pillows Insert
  • Foamily Premium Hypoallergenic Throw Pillow Insert
  • Edow Throw Pillow Inserts
  • Phantoscope Throw Pillow Inserts
  • Oubonun Throw Pillow Inserts

How do I choose a pillow insert?

There are several factors that will come into play when choosing the best throw pillow insert for your needs.

These will include how many pillow inserts you need, whether you need hypoallergenic throw pillow inserts, what size you need, how easy they are to clean, how durable they will be, as well as how much budget you have to play with.

What material is best for a pillow insert?

The best material for pillow inserts will depend on your personal preferences, and whether you have an allergy for a particular material. Some people prefer to use feather down inserts because these give you the firmness and support you need.

However, people who suffer from certain allergies may prefer to opt for a hypoallergenic insert, such as a microfiber filling.